The Bear Bile Trade

Rescued Asiatic black bears,Andrew & Ginny at play

INTRODUCTION

“How does a bear, that has spent 22 years confined in a tiny wire cage and is tortured twice daily through bile extraction from a tube in his stomach, come to put such total trust in the same species that caused him pain?” asks Jill Robinson MBE, Founder of Animals Asia Foundation who as a Consultant to the International Fund for Animal Welfare discovered a ‘bear farm’ in China where Asiatic black Bears were tightly confined within tiny wire cages so that their bile could be ‘milked’ for traditional medicine.

In a major breakthrough in July 2000, Animals Asia signed an historic Agreement with the authorities in Beijing and Sichuan to free 500 suffering endangered Moon Bears from the worst farms in China.  Most importantly, the agreement pledges to work towards the end of bear farming once and for all. 

BACKGROUND 

The Asiatic black bear (Ursus Selenarctos Thibetanus) is one of the 8 bear species in the world and is listed under the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES) as Appendix I – the most critical category of endangerment.  No-one knows how many of these animals remain in the wild, but the rampant demand for their body parts and loss of habitat causes their numbers to dwindle catastrophically. One of the most significant impacts on their population is the demand for their gall bladders and bile juice which is used in traditional Oriental medicine Asia wide and in Asian communities throughout the world.

  Catheters used to extract the bile  

 

Bowl of bile juice

In the early 1980's, North Korea began taking bears as cubs from the wild, caging them, and surgically implanting them with catheters, so that bile could be extracted on a regular basis whilst keeping the animal alive. A few years later, Chinese scientists adopted the same procedure as it was considered that the practice would satisfy the local demand - whilst reducing the number of animals taken from the wild. However, by the early 1990's, there were nearly five hundred bear farms in operation, holding more than 10,000 bears.     

A THOUSAND MILES STARTS WITH ONE STEP

 In 1994, following worldwide exposure of the practice and intensive negotiations from within China itself, an announcement was made by the China Wildlife Conservation Association (CWCA), Jill Robinson and IFAW, the Chinese Association of Medicine and Philosophy and EarthCare which called for the future elimination of bear farming.  Although this was an agreement between non-government groups, this initiative was to set the scene for helping the bears in the years to come. True to their word, in 1995 the Chinese authorities closed down the worst farm which Jill had previously visited and gave IFAW custody of the bears who had been exposed to such terrible suffering.  Since December 1996, 7 bears have lived a free, enriched and happy life in a semi natural sanctuary funded by IFAW and managed by Jill and the team of Animals Asia.  

Reaching out for help 

THE BREAKTHROUGH 

Hong Kong, July 2000, the Animals Asia Foundation with officials from the China Wildlife Conservation Association in Beijing and the Sichuan Forestry Department announced a landmark Agreement which would free 500 endangered “Moon” bears from a lifetime of captivity and suffering on bear farms in China. The agreement announced three major goals:

  • to close the worst farms in Sichuan and build a sanctuary for 500 bears

  • to expand this initiative to other provinces in China

  • to end bear farming and provide care and refuge for the remaining bears

The Agreement also declared that the groups were united in supporting the manufacture and use of non-endangered herbal and synthetic substitutes to bear bile and, together, would encourage current and potential consumers to refuse the use of any product containing bear bile. Animals Asia also agreed to pay a level of compensation to the farmers in an effort to ensure that none of the farmed bears were slaughtered for their parts and to help impoverished farmers move into alternative areas of employment.  The Sichuan government agreed to pass the original bear farm licenses to Animals Asia and a country wide policy in China now ensures that no new bear farm licenses are being issued.        

FROM FARMS TO FREEDOM 

 On 13th October  2000, the farms began to close and the bears began arriving at the temporary rescue centre in Chengdu, Sichuan Province. Animals Asia was advised to expect over 60 bears during the following weeks. The first three bears to arrive on the truck were immediately named  and ‘Gail’ (named after the Animals Asia Vet - Dr. Gail Cochrane), ‘Andrew’ and ‘Melody’ became the first ambassadors of the China Bear Rescue. ‘Andrew’ a probable victim of a leg hold trap and missing a limb, ‘Andrew’ was also a young healthy male who showed the team from the second he arrived how forgiving and intelligent this species could be.  Whilst ‘Gail’ and ‘Melody’ growled and ‘woofed’ constant warnings, Andrew lay on his back and playfully tugged at the stray pieces of metal protruding  from his cage. Upon further observation of all three bears, Gail noted that both ‘Andrew’ and ‘Melody’ had metal catheter implants protruding from their abdomens, whilst bear ‘Gail’ had the older style latex catheter - which exited under the skin in her thigh - and teeth which had been deliberately cut back by a farmer who had taken away her defences to make her easier to milk.

Confined 24/7, month after month, year after year 

Over the next few weeks, as more bears arrived, the team of Animals Asia could only watch in horror as truck after truck offloaded animals whose physical and mental condition defied belief. The crude insertion of the catheters into their gall bladders meant that the bleeding and seeping wounds in their stomachs could never heal.  The tightness of the cage around  their bodies had caused injuries and scars up to four feet long.  The lack of exercise had caused their foot pads to dry and painfully crack;  their claws couldn’t be worn down and had grown out of control; puncturing the delicate tissue of the pads. Their mental condition was just as tragic - many had broken and worn down teeth, or vicious wounds on their heads from where they had bitten the cage bars or banged their heads against the metal in a frenzied attempt to stimulate their intelligent and active minds.  Many were violently stereotypic; spending their waking hours rocking back and forth in a pathetic attempt to relieve their boredom and pain. Ranging in age from cubs to middle and old aged, the bears were brought into the safety of the rescue centre and given fruit and jam and tender loving care for the first time in their lives.
     
 
Mass physiotherapy, bears have to stretch for treats

Mr. Deng Xiangsui - Sichuan Forestry Department, China, “Traditionally, bear bile is considered as a precious medicine in China and within the whole Confucian culture.  We recognise in the long run that it is essential to find bile alternatives and to eliminate bear farms.”

Mr. Huang Jian Hua - CWCA, Beijing, China, “Certainly, the Rescue Centre is only an emergency measure taken in the short term.  In the long term, our ultimate goal is to eliminate all bear farming and return the bears back to nature, where they belong, to spend the rest of their life.  I hope that together, through our relentless efforts, this goal will be reached very soon.

GETTING TO KNOW THE BEARS! 

It’s almost impossible to describe the sheer pleasure of seeing bears who have spent a lifetime behind bars now playing tag with each other and enjoying the simple pleasure of sunbathing in the long grass. With nearly all the surgeries complete to remove the implants or correct the problems associated with the new, so-called humane, “free-dripping” method, the sanctuary is becoming full of happy, healthy bears. The dens, designed by Boris Chiao, are an incredible success and have the wonderful addition of “hanging basket beds” which the bears love to climb into (sometimes together!) and which, most importantly, give them much needed security and warmth. Each day, the recovering bears are encouraged to stretch up on depleted hind legs for treats such as strawberry jam and honey (what else!), whilst gradually being integrated with each other in groups ranging from disabled cubs, to small de-clawed females, to those which are equally matched in size.

FAQs ABOUT THE USE OF BEAR BILE    
What about the presence of black market goods made from bear bile?
 It is crucial that this is addressed - Asiatic black bear gall bladders and bile are found across the Asia continent and within consuming traditional Oriental communities worldwide.  However, bear farming is not going to solve the problem, which is why it is so important for groups to merge and encourage and support the traditional Oriental medicine communities in producing and promoting the non endangered herbal and synthetic alternatives to bear bile.  

How can the usage of bear bile be reduced? For some years, together with IFAW,  Animals Asia have been working with practitioners of traditional Oriental medicine to replace the use of all animals used in medicines and preparations with the non-endangered herbal and synthetic alternatives.  This not only helps the animals but elevates the reputation of traditional medicine as being environmentally friendly and cruelty free.  Animals Asia is also embarking on a public education programme in China and Asia (there is a big black market in bear bile in Japan, Korea and Taiwan) which will be aimed at pointing out the cruelty of bear farming and persuading current and potential consumers of bear bile to take the cheap and abundant herbal and synthetic substitutes instead. 

HOW YOU CAN HELP THE BEARS 
Remember the agony the caged bears suffer every day.  Think how you can stretch in your bed at night and of the thousands of bears who cannot enjoy even this basic pleasure. Find out more at www.animalsasia.org


Jill Robinson MBE & Herman





















Pho
tos courtesy of Animals Asia Foundation

No material on this website may be copied or published elsewhere without permission.

 (c) Ooze Online 2001 - 2005